This shows up if the player(s) fail to do the following: -Escape the level within the Lap 4/WAR timer. -Escape within the time limit on most levels. -Escape the Castle before it gets totally obliterated in the final level within the time limit. (The 4 bosses and everyone else you saved at that point will appear alongside Normal Pridgette and Dark Pridgette on the time-up screen.) -Defeat Dark Pridgette within the time limit during her boss fight. (She will appear alongside regular Pridgette during this screen) -Avoid getting caught by this game's Pizzaface after the timer reaches zero during the escape sequence.
Credit to all.