lol yeah this is similar to those cartoon characters same person theory like how the flying dutchman and patchy the pirate are the same person. it would be funny if someone thought that 5pud the skeleton is the skeleton of Spud/Me well i mean we wear the same shirt and jacket but we wear different shorts and shoes well it's not really that much of a nail in the coffin that it's true cause they both have a crush on miku and hate Cloud/Storm and love the same foods again it's not really that much of a nail in the coffin that it's true cause there both alive at the same time but what if there from different timelines where in one timeline Spud gets Unalived and in the other Spud is still alive but I mean if I were to prove it soon i would have to make a project that show Spud getting Unalived and 5pud comes out of his grave or out of his body(I know it sounds graphic)
