Basing this on the last game each item appeared in. Not counting items from the arcade games. S Tier: Bowser Shell, Bullet Bill, Chain Chomp, Crazy Eight, Giga Bob-Omb, Golden Mushroom, Lightning, Lucky Seven, Star, & Triple Mushrooms A Tier: Bob-Omb, Boomerang Flower, Capsule, Coin Box, Double Bob-Ombs, Ice Flower, Mega Mushroom, Mushroom Cannon, Piranha Plant, Super Horn, & Triple Red Shells B Tier: Banana Cannon, Birdo Egg, Dash Ring, Fire Flower, Fireball, Giant Banana, Heart, POW Block, Red Shell, Super Bell, & Yoshi Egg C Tier: Coin, Poison Mushroom, Super Leaf, Triple Bananas, & Triple Green Shells D Tier: Banana, Feather, & Green Shell F Tier: Blooper, Boo, Blue Shell, Bob-Omb Cannon, Bubble, Fake Item Box, & Thunder Cloud
1st: Bullet Bill 2nd: Chain Chomp 3rd: Crazy Eight 4th: Lucky Seven 5th: Bowser Shell 6th: Lightning 7th: Star 8th: Golden Mushroom 9th: Triple Mushrooms 10th: Giga Bob-Omb 11th: Super Horn 12th: Ice Flower 13th: Double Bob-Ombs 14th: Boomerang Flower 15th: Triple Red Shells 16th: Piranha Plant 17th: Coin Box 18th: Mushroom Cannon 19th: Mushroom 20th: Hammer 21st: Capsule 22nd: Bob-Omb 23rd: Mega Mushroom 24th: Giant Banana 25th: POW Block 26th: Fire Flower 27th: Fireball 28th: Dash Ring 29th: Heart 30th/31st: Birdo Egg/Yoshi Egg 32nd: Red Shell 33rd: Banana Cannon 34th: Super Bell 35th: Triple Green Shells 36th: Poison Mushroom 37th: Triple Bananas 38th: Super Leaf 39th: Coin 40th: Feather 41st: Green Shell 42nd: Banana 43rd: Blue Shell 44th: Bubble 45th: Bob-Omb Cannon 46th: Fake Item Box 47th: Boo 48th: Blooper 49th: Thunder Cloud
