ScratchData LogoScratchData
Back to popswilson's profile

Grecian Urn

POpopswilson•Created June 14, 2015
Grecian Urn
9
8
121 views
View on Scratch

Instructions

A Grecian urn contains 75 white beans and 150 black beans. Next to the urn is a pile of 200 black beans. Pick two beans at random from the urn. If at least one of the beans is black, place it on the pile and drop the other bean, whether white or black, back into the urn. If both beans are white, discard both white beans, pick a black bean from the pile and drop it into the urn. Question: Will there ever be just one bean in the urn and if, so, what will be its color? Click on the green flag to find out.

Description

This problem appeared in A.K. Dewdney's Mathematical Recreations column, March 1991, Scientific American. The problem originated with Ross Honsberger, University of Waterloo, Canada. Not having a Grecian urn and an assortment of white and black beans handy, I decided to write a Scratch simulation. This problem illustrates the curious fact that even though the process of drawing the beans is random, the outcome is purely deterministic! Questions: 1. What is the outcome, every time? 2. Does the program always terminate at the same Draw#?

Project Details

Project ID67083730
CreatedJune 14, 2015
Last ModifiedNovember 19, 2023
SharedJune 15, 2015
Visibilityvisible
CommentsAllowed