So, Dovestrike definitely has an injured eye behind the floof. I do think @LinkScratchStar did a theory about this a while ago, but I'm not exactly sure. Anyway, basically, it is believed that Dovestrike got her eye injury when she "hurt Boulderpatch" However, it doesn't look like a scar given to her by another cat. It looks a bit like Brightheart's scar, to be honest. I can't really tell, though, since most of her floof is still in the way. So my theory is maybe this. What if, she did get the scar when she hurt Boulderpatch? But she didn't do it intentionally. My theory is Dovestrike/paw was with another cat that Boulderpatch cared about a lot, like a relative. A fox, badger, or dog may have shown up and killed the other cat and injured Dovestrike. In the project "The Accident" that Rainboo shared a while ago, it showed Dovepaw standing a distance away from a cat covered in blood. Dovepaw had that injured eye. However, she didn't have blood on her paws or teeth, certainly not enough to show that she killed the bloody cat. I think that it was actually an accident, but Boulderpatch blames Dovestrike anyway.
