I thought of this way before Animation Rewind
Read after your done ya done? sure? Ok The winner is bendy, but is isn't hard to decide, but at the same time, not easy. Bendy and Baldi goes back and forth with stats. Bendy has strength, Baldi has a slight edge in speed, bendy has fighting skill, Baldi has intelligence. Bendy has fighting experience, Baldi has home court advantage. But the thing is, only one edge is physical. And you could say, "You can't hit ink, so Bendy won't get damaged at all!" well, thats wrong. As shown, in Chapters 2, 3, and 4, you can punch and hit ink creatures with pipes and other stuff. But the edges that really gave the win were strength and durability. Bendy is stronger than Franken-Boris, which can toss metal cars and hit the ground hard enough to make it crumble with ease and even he isn't strong enough to one shot us like Bendy can. And durability, Bendy can tank hits from gun fire. Sure, the ammo is ink, but it is still a gun. And we all know how much a paint gun hurts. So bendy being able to be unaffected by a rapid fire paint gun is impressive to a guy who's strongest feat is from a giant broom