If you're in the camp: Do the challenge first. Then press space. If you're not in the camp: Press space. If you're Boris: Observe and judge. If you somehow don't fit in any of the above groups: Stop breaking reality.
Credit to Boris and everyone in the camp. Fun fact relating to the title: When the Dutch owned the area containing New York, the city was called New Amsterdam. When the British took the area for themselves, they renamed the city to New York, a name that has stuck to this day.