This theory is part of a series of theories. I would suggest starting here: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/1057211509/ Sorry this took so long I have map parts and low motivation :’D. When you see '[next]' use the right arrow key, spacebar, or click to go to the next image [next] This theory will be (party) based of my disproved Violetant theory: https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/1055448275/ In this theory I thought that ???star was Stingstar, and since Stingstar is Redeye’s half sister and Violetant has the same eye color as Redeye, I assumed that Violetant was their mother. (which has obviously not true). The bulk of this old theory has been discarded, I think there are still salvageable parts. [next] For example, I theorized that Violetant was a wanderer who moved clans because she knew how to hunt owls despite Riverclan territory’s lack of trees. I still believe this, and it also lines up with the rest of my theories. [next] Since she shares ‘The Bite of ‘87’ with the Wolf (Adderpaw) and BSC, she would obviously have to be wrapped up in their scheme. An idea I have is that she knows BSC besides the entire scheme thing. She could be a childhood friend, sister, or mate. I think this could be a fun idea and be an explanation for BSC origin. [next] I have several ideas on how Violetant is wrapped up in all this drama, but here are some. One is that BSC and Violetant originally were born in Shadowclan, but that she moved because she liked Riverclan better. There are still a lot of things that could vary, but I think it had something to do with the deputy of Riverclan. The could have the perfect puppet ready, and the only thing getting in the way was that cat who was second in line. Violetant could be the deputy herself (girlboss) and be killed, or, what I think is more likely, she could witness the death of said deputy. I think this would be much more interesting, and when BSC would find out, he would track her down and kill her. This would really show his lack of empathy, and would be an interesting end to Violetant’s character. The other possibility is Violetant moving to Shadowclan with BSC against her better judgement. At first, she could have thought it was an innocent move and been along for the ride, but then she could have again witnessed a murder. She could have been silenced as she was in the first scenario, but I also think it would be interesting if BSC kept her alive but silenced her in other ways, perhaps manipulation, black-mail, or threats to her or someone she loved. I think the most likely method though is making others think she’s crazy and losing her mind as she gets older (BSC would really be putting the gaslight in gaslight gatekeep girlboss). I think this would be super fun to read about. [next] Now that my (outlandish) theorizing is over, let’s go over something concrete, the lyrics and symbolism of ‘Bite of ‘87’. From what I understand (I don’t play FNAF), the bite of 87 was an event where the animatronics bit off a human’s eye, causing them to be locked in a closet. In EA terms, I imagine this meaning the cats responsible for the ‘Bite of ‘87’ equivalent were sent to the dark forest for their action. Music-wise, I get very ‘Room Where it Happened’ vibes, especially because some of the reoccurring lines are ‘I was there when it happened’ and ‘I know who’s responsible’. [next] Now that the overviews over, let’s go onto the lyrics. I won’t be breaking down every verse, since most of it is pop culture and FNAF references, only the chorus and what I deem important lyrics. (CHORUS) I know who's responsible For the "Bite of '87" I was there all when it happened No really, no really, hear me out You've got to trust me now Everybody's so obsessive Over how or when or where it happened Why don't you hear me out? Remember how I said BSC would silence her by making others think she’s crazy? Well, this is what I feel most supports that theory. In this chorus she seems to be desperately begging the listener to believe her, which sounds to me like she’s used to being brushed off or laughed at. [next] (IMPORTANT LYRIC 1) Here comes the star of the show The big brown bear on that Freddy Faz-flow Little baby, little boy De(headed) like an old chew toy Here comes the star of the show The big brown bear on that Freddy Faz-flow Was that the "Bite of '87"? Don't worry, he's up in heaven I think that Freddy here is either Featherstar or Redeye, probably Featherstar given that they are literally described as ‘the star of the show’. I assume this is Violetant seeing their murder, or ‘The Bite of ‘87’. After this, Featherstar goes up to Starclan, just like the lyrics. [next] (IMPORTANT LYRIC 2) Here comes the star of the show The big brown bear on that Freddy Faz-flow Foxy however, was looking quite sus He was the Impostor from Among Us I feel like this is before Featherstar’s murder. Perhaps Violetant sees BSC acting suspicious or bitter around Featherstar. (CONT)
Violet might be confused at first, but decide not to read into it because she’s known BSC since she was young and trusted him. (IMPORTANT LYRIC 3) Why don't you seem more surprised? I promise I'm not telling lies Wait 'til you hear the rest of the story You'll unsub to Game Theory I believe this is whoever she is talking to brushing her off again because of how crazy her story sounds. Game Theory in this scenario would probably be BSC or Shadowclan’s otherwise corrupt government. And that is my theory on how Violetant relates to all of this :D Part 5: Soon (hopefully) Characters, art, and story by @Meadowfoot_ToPH
